Skip to content
Amarula Christmas Trifle

Amarula Christmas Trifle

Every South African family has a trifle bowl that only comes out in December. Ours lives at the back of the cupboard for eleven months, then becomes the most important dish on the table.

This version keeps everything you remember (wobbly Moirs jelly, Koo peaches and a thick layer of custard) and swaps the sherry for Amarula. Romany Creams go in the base instead of sponge, so the chocolate melts into the cream liqueur as it sets. Build it the day before and it only gets better overnight.

Serves: 8 to 10 · Prep: 40 minutes · Setting time: at least 6 hours, ideally overnight

Ingredients

Method

  1. Jelly first. Make up both packets of jelly following the pack instructions, but use 100ml less water in total so it sets firmer. Let it cool to room temperature.
  2. Custard next. Mix the custard powder and sugar with a few spoons of the milk to make a paste. Heat the rest of the milk until steaming, whisk it into the paste, return to the pan and stir over a medium heat until really thick. Add the vanilla. Press cling film onto the surface and leave it to cool.
  3. Biscuit base. Break the Romany Creams in half and pack them into the bottom of a large glass trifle bowl. Mix the Amarula with 3 tablespoons of the peach syrup and spoon it evenly over the biscuits.
  4. Peaches. Slice the peach halves and lay most of them over the soaked biscuits. Keep 6 to 8 slices for the top.
  5. Set the jelly. Pour the cooled jelly gently over the peaches. Refrigerate for 3 to 4 hours until set.
  6. Custard layer. Spread the cooled custard over the set jelly. Chill for another hour.
  7. Top it off. Whip the cream with the icing sugar to soft peaks and spread it over the custard. Finish with the reserved peach slices, grated chocolate and toasted almonds. Chill until you serve.

For the kids: use only peach syrup for the soak and skip the Amarula. Make a small separate bowl if the adults want theirs boozy.

Tip: let the jelly cool properly before it goes over the biscuits. Warm jelly turns the base to mush.

Shop the recipe

Next article Christmas Malva Pudding with Van Der Hum Sauce

Leave a comment

Comments must be approved before appearing

* Required fields